Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Heart failure doesn't mean your heart failed

The name terrifies people for no good reason, and the treatment changed more in the last six years than in the thirty before it.

By Cal Brennan · Fitness6 min read
Share
Heart failure doesn't mean your heart failed

A cardiologist says "heart failure" and the patient hears "my heart is quitting and I should get my affairs in order." What the cardiologist actually means is narrower and far less dramatic: the pump isn't moving enough blood for what the body's asking, at pressures the rest of the plumbing can tolerate. That's it. The heart didn't resign. It got demoted.

It's a terrible name. It's been a terrible name since the 1800s, and the field is stuck with it. Meanwhile the treatment has changed so much in the past six years that advice your uncle got in 2015 is genuinely out of date.

If you're reading this because a father, a wife or you personally just got the word, the useful part starts now.

The number on the echo report, decoded

Ejection fraction is the fraction of blood sitting in the left ventricle that gets pushed out on each beat. Normal is somewhere around 55 to 70 percent. Nobody hits 100. The ventricle never empties, and it isn't supposed to.

So when a report says EF 60%, that's a healthy heart, not a heart running at "60 percent capacity." People misread that constantly and lose a night of sleep over it.

Below 40 percent, you're in what's called HFrEF, heart failure with reduced ejection fraction. That's the classic weak-pump version. Between 41 and 49 is "mildly reduced." At 50 and above with real symptoms, it's HFpEF, preserved ejection fraction, where the pump squeezes fine but the muscle has gotten stiff and won't relax and fill properly between beats.

The distinction matters because until recently, one of those had a full arsenal of drugs and the other had basically nothing.

The four pillars, and why they're all started at once now

For reduced EF, treatment is built on four drug classes. An ARNI like sacubitril/valsartan, or an ACE inhibitor if that's not an option. A beta blocker. A mineralocorticoid receptor antagonist, usually spironolactone. And an SGLT2 inhibitor, dapagliflozin or empagliflozin.

The old approach was sequential. Start one, max it out over a couple of months, add the next, repeat. Patients died waiting for step three.

The current approach is to get all four started quickly at low doses and titrate up from there. Lower doses of four beats maximum doses of two. That change alone is one of the bigger wins in cardiology this decade, and it costs nothing extra to implement.

Two things nobody warns you about. First, your blood pressure will probably drop and you may feel lightheaded for the first few weeks while your body adjusts. That's expected, and it's a conversation with the prescriber, not a reason to quietly stop taking something. Second, the SGLT2 inhibitor was originally a diabetes drug. You'll get a pharmacist or a relative asking why you're on a diabetes medication when you don't have diabetes. The answer is that it turned out to help the heart through a mechanism nobody fully predicted, which is one of the more honest things medicine has admitted lately.

The stiff-heart half finally has something

HFpEF is roughly half of all heart failure, it skews older, and for decades the treatment was "manage the blood pressure and the fluid and hope." Trial after trial came back empty.

SGLT2 inhibitors broke that streak. They're now recommended in preserved EF too. It isn't a cure, but it's the first thing in a very long time that moved the needle on hospitalizations for that group.

There's a second thing worth knowing about, because it's badly underdiagnosed. A slice of older men labeled HFpEF actually have cardiac amyloidosis, where a misfolded protein infiltrates the heart muscle and stiffens it. The tell-tale history is often a thickened heart on echo plus carpal tunnel surgery years earlier, sometimes spinal stenosis, sometimes a torn biceps tendon. It used to be a diagnosis with nothing behind it. Now there's a nuclear scan that finds it without a biopsy, and there are drugs that slow it down.

If that history sounds like your dad, say the word "amyloid" out loud at the next appointment. Worst case, you get told no.

Weigh yourself every morning. Same time, same clothes.

This is the highest-value unglamorous habit in the whole condition. Fluid builds up before you feel it. The scale catches it days before the shortness of breath does.

Same time every morning, after the bathroom, before breakfast, same amount of clothing. Write it down somewhere you'll actually keep. The standard threshold to call the clinic is a gain of two to three pounds in a day or about five pounds in a week. That's fluid, not fat. Nobody eats five pounds of steak in a week.

Other signals to take seriously: needing an extra pillow to breathe at night, waking up gasping an hour after falling asleep, ankles that leave a dent when you press them, and getting winded when you bend over to tie your shoes. That last one has a name, bendopnea, and it's a real sign.

Check your medicine cabinet before you check anything else

Ibuprofen and naproxen make the body hold onto sodium and water and blunt some of the heart drugs. Regular use is a known way to end up back in the hospital. The bottle in your truck door counts.

Decongestants in cold medicine are the other one. Pseudoephedrine and phenylephrine raise blood pressure, which is the last thing a struggling ventricle needs in February.

Neither of these is on a warning label in letters big enough to notice. Ask the pharmacist. They'll tell you free and they'll tell you in thirty seconds.

On salt, the guidance has actually gotten less aggressive. The SODIUM-HF trial tested strict restriction against usual care and didn't find the hard-outcome benefit everyone assumed was there. That doesn't mean go eat a jar of pickles. It means the misery of chasing 1,500 milligrams a day may not be buying what people were told it buys, and it's a reasonable thing to ask your cardiologist about instead of suffering on principle.

Exercise is treatment, not a risk to be avoided

The old instruction was rest. That was wrong, and it cost people a lot of function. Supervised exercise improves symptoms, capacity and quality of life, and cardiac rehab is one of the most underused referrals in the entire system. If nobody has offered it, ask.

For the day-to-day, two rules do most of the work.

Use effort, not heart rate. Beta blockers flatten your heart rate response, so every zone chart and every watch estimate lies to you. Use the talk test. Conversational pace means you're in the right place. If you can't finish a sentence, back off.

Lift something twice a week. Not heroically. Sit-to-stands, a loaded carry down the hallway, a press with whatever's in the garage. Muscle is how you stay out of a chair at 80, and the chair is what actually ends people.

Walk most days. Ten minutes counts. Ten minutes done for two years beats an hour done for nine days, and it isn't close.

None of this substitutes for a cardiologist who knows your echo, your labs and your kidneys, and the medication decisions in here are theirs to make, not yours or mine. Go get the numbers. Bring the questions. A diagnosis with four proven drugs behind it's a very different animal from the one the name suggests.

Share this article

Cal Brennan

Fitness

Strength coach. Trains fathers, tradesmen and desk workers, which means programmes that survive a bad week.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Fitness.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Jeff Nippard28 Sept

    Peptides Are Insane

    Jeff Nippard23 Sept

    How Bodybuilding Workouts Evolved From 1900 To Now

    Jeff Nippard15 Sept

    I Ranked 10 Foods: Highest To Lowest Calories

    Peter Attia MD12 Feb

    Simple and effective 2-day strength training program for beginners | Mike Israetel and Peter Attia