Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Buy the Same Shirt Five Times

A shopping-averse man can solve his office wardrobe in one afternoon and a tailor visit, then not think about it again for three years.

By Tobias Reed · Style & Grooming5 min read
Share
Buy the Same Shirt Five Times

The trick is buying five of the same shirt.

Not five shirts. Five copies of one shirt, in the same color, same collar, same cut. Then two pairs of trousers that work with all of them, one jacket that works with the trousers, and two pairs of shoes. That's a functioning office wardrobe. Most men who hate shopping own thirty garments and can assemble maybe four outfits they actually feel good in. You want eight garments and twenty outfits, and you want the whole thing bought in an afternoon.

I know a guy who's worn the same white oxford to work for six years. He owns seven. When one frays at the collar, it becomes a weekend shirt and he orders another. Nobody at his office has ever noticed, and he's never once stood in front of a closet at 6:40 in the morning wondering what to do.

Pick the uniform before you leave the house

Decide two things at your kitchen table, not in a store under fluorescent light while a salesperson watches you.

One: what does your office actually wear? Look at the two or three men there who seem to have it handled. Not the most senior man, who may be immune to judgment. The ones in the middle who look pulled together. Are they in a jacket most days? Ever a tie? Are the shoes leather or something softer? You're not copying them. You're establishing the ceiling and floor so you don't overshoot in either direction.

Two: what's your base color? Navy or charcoal. Pick one and build everything around it. Navy is friendlier and reads better in daylight. Charcoal is harder to get wrong and hides more. Brown and olive are fine for men who like clothes. You don't, so skip them.

That's the whole planning stage. Ten minutes.

The list

For a standard office, in a city, where a jacket is expected sometimes but not always:

  • Five dress shirts. White or light blue, or three and two. Point collar or semi-spread. Not button-down if you wear a tie often, button-down if you never do.
  • Two pairs of wool trousers in your base color. Flat front. Wool is the point. It breathes, it holds a crease, it doesn't look sad by 4pm the way cheap poly-blends do.
  • One suit in the same base color. Wear the jacket with the odd trousers on jacket days, wear the whole thing when someone dies or gets married or you have to present to people who can fire you.
  • One knit. Merino crewneck or a fine-gauge half-zip, navy or gray. This is your layer for cold offices and for the days you can't face a jacket.
  • Two pairs of shoes. One dark brown leather derby or loafer, one black. Brown gets worn four days out of five.
  • Socks in one color. Buy twelve identical pairs of dark navy or charcoal. You will never sort socks again. This is a genuinely underrated quality-of-life improvement.
  • One belt matched to the brown shoes, one to the black.

That's it. Add a raincoat if you live somewhere it rains, which you already knew.

Do it in one afternoon, and go on a Tuesday

Saturday stores are a scrum. Go Tuesday at 2pm if you can, or Thursday evening. You want a salesperson with nothing better to do than measure you.

Say this when you walk in: "I need five shirts, two pairs of trousers and a navy suit. I'm not here to browse. What fits a man shaped like me?" That sentence cuts an hour off the visit and completely changes how you get treated. Salespeople are used to men who won't commit. A man who knows what he wants gets the good help.

Get measured properly while you're there. Neck, sleeve, chest, waist, inseam. Type all of it into your phone right then, in a note called "sizes." Once you have those numbers and a model name that fit, you can reorder from your couch for years. That's the actual escape hatch. The store visit is a one-time cost you pay to buy the right to never go again.

Try on one shirt and one pair of trousers. Not five. If the fit is right, buy the stack.

Everything goes to the tailor, same day

Walk straight from the store to a tailor with the whole bag. Drop it all at once.

Trouser hem, jacket sleeves, and a light take-in at the shirt waist if the shirts balloon. That's usually the entire job. Ask for a plain hem with no cuff unless you have a strong feeling, and tell them you want the trouser to touch the top of the shoe with a slight break. Bring the shoes you'll actually wear. Hemming trousers without the right shoes is how you end up with pants that look correct in the shop and wrong on a Monday.

Budget something in the range of a nice dinner for the alterations on a couple of garments. Sleeve shortening on a jacket costs more than a hem, and moving buttonholes costs more again, which is why you check the jacket sleeves carefully before buying.

The unglamorous truth about tailoring is the turnaround. Ten days is normal. Two weeks in December. So don't do this the week before you start a new job.

What goes wrong

Color creep. Eighteen months in, you buy a green shirt because it was on sale. Then a checked one. Now you have decisions again. Hold the line.

The shirt gets discontinued. It will. The moment you find one that fits, buy two spares and put them in a drawer. That buys you three more years.

You wear the same shoes every day and kill them in a year. Leather needs a day off to dry out. Alternating two pairs roughly doubles their life. Cedar shoe trees, in the shoe the moment you take it off, do more for the shape of a shoe than anything else you can buy for that money.

You wash shirts too hot and dry them in the machine. Cold wash, hang them damp on a hanger, and most of the wrinkles fall out by morning. This is the difference between ironing five shirts a week and ironing none.

When this advice is wrong

If your office is a design studio, a startup floor, or anywhere with a culture of personal expression, a rigid uniform can read as a man who isn't paying attention. Same if you're client-facing in an industry where clothes are part of the signal. And if you genuinely enjoy clothes, this whole approach robs you of something you like. Then don't do it.

But most men reading this don't like clothes and shouldn't have to. You want to look like you respect the room, and you want the decision made before you wake up.

Set a calendar reminder for thirty-six months out. One line: reorder shirts, check shoes. Then close the closet and go do your job.

Share this article

Tobias Reed

Style & Grooming

Spent a decade in menswear retail watching men buy the wrong size. Believes fit is ninety per cent of it and says so weekly.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from City Style.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Gentleman's Gazette7 Oct

    Slim Enough for a Breast Pocket #mensstyle #innovation

    Gentleman's Gazette27 Sept

    15 Little Things Only True Gentlemen Do (That Have a Big Impact)

    Gentleman's Gazette20 Sept

    I'm A Custom Clothier: Here Are My Favorite Jackets

    Mens Fashioner28 Feb

    How To Wear Black Sneakers | Men’s Shoe Style Advice | Men’s Shoes