Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Prediabetes is a head start, not a number to sit on

An A1c of 5.9 is the most useful bad news you'll get all year, if you do something with it in the next 90 days.

By Cal Brennan · Fitness6 min read
Prediabetes is a head start, not a number to sit on

You open the lab portal at 9:40 at night because that's when the house finally goes quiet, and there's a little yellow flag next to a line you've never read before. A1c 5.9. Under it, a range: 4.0 to 5.6. Nobody called. The note from the office says "borderline, discuss at next visit," and your next visit is in March.

That flag is the single most actionable thing on the page. It's also the one most likely to get ignored, because nothing hurts, nothing's broken, and the word "borderline" sounds like a rounding error.

It isn't. Prediabetes means your body's already having trouble keeping glucose in the normal range, and the trouble started years before the number moved. You've been handed a warning at the stage where the warning still does something. Very little in adult medicine works that way.

The numbers, plainly

The American Diabetes Association draws the lines like this:

  • A1c: 5.7 to 6.4 percent is prediabetes. 6.5 percent or higher, on two tests, is type 2 diabetes.
  • Fasting glucose: 100 to 125 mg/dL is impaired fasting glucose. 126 or higher is diabetes territory.
  • Two-hour glucose after a 75-gram drink: 140 to 199 mg/dL.

You only need one of those to be flagged. A1c is the usual one because it doesn't require fasting and it reflects roughly the last three months of blood sugar rather than the morning you happened to skip breakfast.

Two things about A1c that your printout won't tell you. First, it's an estimate built on red blood cell lifespan, so anemia, kidney disease, recent blood loss, pregnancy and some hemoglobin variants can push it up or down without your glucose doing anything. If your A1c looks odd next to the rest of your labs, ask whether a fasting glucose or a fructosamine makes more sense for you. Second, 5.7 and 6.4 aren't the same situation. A 5.7 is a nudge. A 6.3 means you're one bad year from a diagnosis that follows you onto every insurance form you ever fill out.

Why "watch it" is the worst advice in the folder

Because "watch it" has no verb in it. Nobody watches anything. You close the portal, the kid's science project is due, and the next A1c is 6.2.

The alternative isn't a cleanse. The Diabetes Prevention Program, the big randomized trial that set the standard here, gave people two modest targets: lose 7 percent of body weight and get 150 minutes a week of moderate activity. Over about three years, that cut progression to type 2 diabetes by 58 percent compared with placebo. Metformin, the drug, cut it by 31 percent. The lifestyle arm beat the pill, and it did it with numbers a working parent can actually hit.

Seven percent on a 210-pound frame is under 15 pounds. A hundred fifty minutes is 22 minutes a day, or three 50-minute sessions, or a walk after dinner plus two lifting days. That's the whole protocol. It got beaten into a curriculum and it's still the best thing going.

The walk after dinner isn't filler

If you only add one habit, add a 10 to 15 minute walk that starts within half an hour of your biggest meal. Working muscle pulls glucose out of the blood without needing much insulin to do it, which is exactly the part of the system that's struggling. The post-meal spike is where a lot of your A1c comes from, and a short walk blunts it.

The reason I push this one first is that it survives contact with real life. It doesn't need a gym, a change of clothes, a babysitter or a 5 a.m. alarm. You take the toddler in the stroller around the block twice. You walk to the mailbox the long way. Nobody has to know you're doing anything.

The trade-off, and it's real: a walk after dinner does nothing for the other 23 hours. It's a patch, not a rebuild.

Muscle is the storage tank

Skeletal muscle is where most of the glucose in your bloodstream ends up. More muscle, working more often, means a bigger tank and a body that clears a meal faster. This is why strength training moves fasting glucose and A1c even when the scale barely budges, and why "just do cardio" undersells the fix.

Two sessions a week is enough to matter. Forty minutes each. Squat or leg press, some kind of hinge, a push, a pull, and carry something heavy for 30 seconds at the end. Load it hard enough that the last two reps are genuinely difficult, because the stimulus is what changes the tissue, not the calendar entry.

If you're starting from nothing with a job and two kids, put the two lifting days on the calendar as recurring appointments and let everything else be walking. Three sessions would be better. Two that you actually do beats four that you plan and skip, and I'd rather you be boring for a year than heroic for six weeks.

Sleep, and the part nobody wants to hear

Short sleep and rotating shifts push insulin resistance up on their own. If you're running on five and a half hours because that's the only way the work gets done, you're fighting the lab result with one hand tied. I'm not going to pretend a parent of young kids can order eight hours. But there's usually 30 to 45 minutes hiding in the phone between 10 and 11 p.m., and that's the cheapest blood sugar intervention available.

Same honesty on food: you don't need a diet name. Get protein and fiber into every meal so it isn't starch alone, and take liquid sugar out entirely. Soda, sweet tea, juice, the 300-calorie coffee. Liquid sugar hits fast, carries no fullness, and is the easiest large win you'll ever bank. Beer counts too.

What to ask at the appointment

Don't wait for March. Call and ask for a nurse visit or a telehealth slot, and bring these:

  • Should we repeat the A1c, or add a fasting glucose? One flagged value is a signal, not a verdict.
  • Am I a candidate for metformin? It's not automatic. The ADA flags it for higher-risk people, including those with A1c at the upper end, a BMI of 35 or more, those under 60, and women with a history of gestational diabetes. It's an honest conversation, not a failure.
  • Can you refer me to a CDC-recognized National Diabetes Prevention Program? It's the year-long version of the trial above, often covered by Medicare and many commercial plans, frequently virtual. A coach and a weigh-in every week beats willpower.
  • What are my triglycerides, HDL and blood pressure doing? These travel together. Fixing one usually moves the others.
  • When do we recheck? Get a date in the chart before you leave.

A registered dietitian or a certified diabetes care and education specialist is worth an hour of your time if your plan covers it. None of this is medical advice for your specific situation, and your doctor has your whole chart, which I don't.

The part that isn't your fault

Some people do the walking, the lifting, the sleep and the soda, and the number still climbs. Type 2 diabetes runs hard in families and the pancreas ages on its own schedule. Progressing isn't a character flaw and it isn't proof you slacked. It means you need medication earlier, and modern medication is very good.

But you get to find that out on your terms, with three years of training in the bank and a doctor who's been watching with you. That's a completely different life than the one where you find out at 52 because your vision went blurry.

The flag on the portal is the head start. Most people never get one.

Cal Brennan

Fitness

Strength coach. Trains fathers, tradesmen and desk workers, which means programs that survive a bad week.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Fitness.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Jeff NippardOct 17

    What Do 100 Calories Actually Look Like?

    Jeff NippardOct 8

    The Best & Worst Peptides (Ranked)

    Jeff NippardSep 28

    Peptides Are Insane

    Peter Attia MDFeb 12

    Simple and effective 2-day strength training program for beginners | Mike Israetel and Peter Attia